Forum Replies Created

  • Shivanand

    Member
    16/11/2024 at 10:01 pm in reply to: Notation

    Allow me to chime in here. Apparently the western standard is over-simplified and treated as a de-facto standard (thanks to the colonial legacy). The Hindustani and Carnatic system uses shrutis (as you researched previously. The Arabic middle eastern music system uses quarter tones instead of semi-tones. So while western system may be able to express articulations, it falls way short of the resolution of notes (that being one shortcoming but not the end of it). Beyond that (and at the risk of my post being flagged as spam) there’s an excellent series why western music had never been able to capture the essence of Arabic / middle-eastern music. So essentially western standard is widespread but mistaken for universal standard.

    https://youtu.be/LR511iAedYU?si=UVOBua6rJ4X50Ds8

    • This reply was modified 6 days, 15 hours ago by  Shivanand.
  • Shivanand

    Member
    01/10/2024 at 7:30 am in reply to: Details of Thaats

    Please find the details of 10 thaats attached.

    For all exercises in RWM modules, the sequence is:

    1. Kalyan

    2. Bilawal

    3. Khamaj

    4. Kafi

    5. Asavari

    6. Bhairavi

    7. Todi

    8. Purvi

    9. Marwa

    10. Bhairav

  • Shivanand

    Member
    25/09/2024 at 4:41 pm in reply to: google Auto tuner

    Please limit the use of this tool to western music. Western music uses Pythagorean tuning. Ancient music such as Hindustani and Carnatic use just-intonation / tuning so this tool will sound out of tune.

  • Shivanand

    Member
    17/09/2024 at 12:22 pm in reply to: google Auto tuner

    Here’s it is:

    https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/transpose-%E2%96%B2%E2%96%BC-pitch-%E2%96%B9-spee/ioimlbgefgadofblnajllknopjboejda